table of contents

05/12/2009

Marília Librandi Rocha on Nuance and Brazil

MARÍLIA LIBRANDI ROCHA specializes in Brazilian literature and culture within a comparative framework. She is particularly focused on the modern period, from the nineteenth century to the present. She was born in São Paulo, where she earned her MA and PhD in Literary Theory and Comparative Literature from the Universidade de São Paulo. From 2004-2008, […]

download transcript [vtt]
00:00:00.000
[ Music ]
00:00:16.000
>> This is KZSU Stanford.
00:00:18.000
Welcome to entitled opinions.
00:00:22.000
My name is Robert Harrison.
00:00:24.000
And we're coming to you from the Stanford campus.
00:00:28.000
[ Music ]
00:00:47.000
Again, that's the Stanford campus where ideas are bursting forth
00:00:51.000
under the spring sun just about everywhere.
00:00:54.000
And again, that's Robert Harrison as in Robert Pogue Harrison,
00:00:59.000
the middle name being the Gaelic word for kiss.
00:01:03.000
When I was younger, I tried hard to get people to call me Pogue,
00:01:06.000
but only one person ever obliged, and she wasn't even Irish.
00:01:10.000
She was Lebanese.
00:01:12.000
Hi, Dagidat, if you're tuning in from London.
00:01:16.000
Robert Pogue Harrison was also my father's name.
00:01:19.000
Everyone called him Pogue when he was growing up.
00:01:22.000
Then he went into the army, and the Irish Americans made jokes
00:01:26.000
about Pogue Mahone.
00:01:29.000
When he got back home from the war, he wanted to be called Bob.
00:01:34.000
I'm not my father's son in that regard.
00:01:37.000
Anything but Bob, if you please, you can't nuance the name Bob,
00:01:42.000
no matter how hard you try.
00:01:45.000
♪ The silence must be clear ♪
00:01:50.000
♪ All day when I'm with her ♪
00:01:54.000
♪ When I come to winter ♪
00:02:00.000
♪ The silence never took me home ♪
00:02:10.000
Our topic today is nuance,
00:02:12.000
which might sound like an eclectic one for a radio show, but stay tuned,
00:02:17.000
because the guest who joins me in the studios of KZSU,
00:02:20.000
María Hosha, recently discourced about nuance in our philosophical reading group,
00:02:26.000
and the radio host immediately thought, "Yes, that's an outstanding theme for a radio show,
00:02:32.000
and she's exactly the person to engage it."
00:02:36.000
In the group, we were discussing the French writer, philosopher Alberkamun,
00:02:40.000
who once wrote in a letter that we must struggle for nuance.
00:02:45.000
What he meant by that, among other things, is that we must struggle against
00:02:49.000
dogmatic ideologies, fundamentalisms,
00:02:52.000
and totalitarian forms of thinking,
00:02:55.000
all of which are poor in nuance, or downright hostile to nuance.
00:03:02.000
If by nuance we mean subtle gradations or variations in color, tone, meaning,
00:03:08.000
or rhythm, it might seem strange that Camru championed it,
00:03:13.000
for he was a famously solar creature who worshiped the blinding light of a southern Mediterranean sun.
00:03:22.000
There is no nuance in the desert, Lawrence of Arabia once declared,
00:03:27.000
referring to the stark alternation between light and dark, day and night.
00:03:32.000
Of course, that statement of Lawrence is itself without nuance, isn't it?
00:03:37.000
Surely in the desert sunsets are more nuance than anywhere else on earth,
00:03:42.000
except perhaps the open sea.
00:03:45.000
On the other hand, it is undeniable that clouds typically introduce nuance
00:03:51.000
into the light that suffuses an atmosphere.
00:03:55.000
As the English painter John Constable knew so well when he spent years
00:04:00.000
studying and painting cloud formations in the early 19th century.
00:04:06.000
It's not by chance that the word nuance comes from the Latin newbies or cloud.
00:04:11.000
Clouds are the very stuff of nuance.
00:04:15.000
Words worth.
00:04:17.000
"Fleecy clouds resting on the hilltops are not easily managed in picture
00:04:23.000
with their accompaniments of blue sky.
00:04:26.000
But how glorious are they in nature?
00:04:29.000
How pregnant with imagination for the poet.
00:04:33.000
Such clouds cleaving to their stations or lifting up suddenly their glittering heads from behind rocky barriers.
00:04:40.000
Or hurrying out of sight with speed of the sharpest edge will often tempt an inhabitant
00:04:46.000
to congratulate himself on belonging to a country of mists and clouds and storms
00:04:53.000
and make him think of the blank sky of Egypt and the cerulean vacancy of Italy
00:05:00.000
as an unanimated and even a sad spectacle."
00:05:06.000
It's a suggestive contrast that words worth draws between English mist and Egyptian solarity,
00:05:14.000
but again we must struggle for nuance.
00:05:17.000
That means resisting stark oppositions.
00:05:21.000
As I said, the desert has its own kind of nuance, different in quality than newbial nuance.
00:05:28.000
If the desert appears as a place without nuance to the western eye,
00:05:33.000
that's because it tends to view the desert abstractly as infinite sky, endless expanse of earth,
00:05:40.000
and bottomless silence.
00:05:42.000
But if you turn your eye and ear away from the emptiness of sky, earth, and silence,
00:05:49.000
and if you focus them on what's happening in and around the square meter of sand around your feet,
00:05:55.000
you'll find that the desert, in fact, purulates with phenomena so discreet as to be practically invisible to the uninitiated eye.
00:06:03.000
Likewise, the desert's silence is never truly vacant but always alive with subtle swirls, echoes, and jinni whispers.
00:06:14.000
The enemy of nuance is abstraction.
00:06:17.000
The struggle for nuance is in some ways a struggle against the conceptual abstractions of philosophy.
00:06:23.000
I'll bet come you learn the hard way that it is very difficult to nuance what you want to say in philosophical language.
00:06:31.000
Literature, on the other hand, is the medium of nuance itself.
00:06:36.000
For literature is the living flesh of philosophy.
00:06:39.000
Not its figurative representation, but its incarnate nuance truth as it were.
00:06:45.000
That is why my guest and I will be making special appeals to literature in our conversation today,
00:06:51.000
but first let me introduce her to you.
00:06:53.000
Maditya Hosha is a new hire for us here at Stanford.
00:06:56.000
She arrived here in January from her native country of Brazil to join the Stanford faculty as an assistant professor of Brazilian literature and culture in the Department of Iberian and Latin American studies.
00:07:09.000
She received her PhD in literary theory and comparative literature in 2003 from the University of San Paolo.
00:07:17.000
Her forthcoming book, "A Bridge Between, Brazilian Fiction and Philosophy" will be coming out shortly.
00:07:26.000
I'm delighted to have her with us and to give her a baptism by fire here on entitled opinions.
00:07:31.000
Maditya, welcome to the program.
00:07:33.000
Thank you Robert. I'm very happy to be here with you.
00:07:37.000
So am I.
00:07:39.000
Maditya, many of us who are not from South America think of rainforests and tropical jungles above all when we think of your home country of Brazil.
00:07:46.000
And I for one think of the rainforest as a place of nuance, Patixilos.
00:07:50.000
Not only because in the forest, sunlight is filtered by clouds, foliage and luxurious canopies, but also because the forest is a place where so many things blend together in color, tone and appearance while at the same time remaining distinct.
00:08:07.000
In the forest, things can hide by remaining discreet, barely distinguishable from the surrounding environment.
00:08:14.000
So the first question I'd like to ask is whether you think it's accurate to say that Brazil by virtue of its very geography and ecology is indeed a place of nuance, Patixilos.
00:08:26.000
Okay, that is a great and beautiful question.
00:08:30.000
And I will start talking about my city, Sam Paolo, who is the opposite sense of the forest.
00:08:42.000
So in fact, when we think about Brazil, we need to remember that Brazil has many diverse eco-resions.
00:08:54.000
And of course, the Amazon rainforests is one of the most important today for all our survival in the world.
00:09:05.000
But your question is important because I agree that Brazil is a place for nuances and plenty of nuances.
00:09:19.000
And do you remember that Camille when he said we need to struggle for nuance?
00:09:26.000
He said nuance not as an abstraction, but as something as vital as men himself.
00:09:35.000
And I think that in Brazil today, there are two forces in conflict.
00:09:42.000
The first one is the force and the importance of nuance in terms of biodiversity, in terms of ecology.
00:09:52.000
And the other force is the force of monocultures that are distracting the biodiversity of Amazon rainforests of seahad, do of septan, etc.
00:10:06.000
So by monocultures, you mean actually a biologically diverse environment which is transformed into, for example, ranch lands or cultivation of just one single kind of crop.
00:10:19.000
Exactly.
00:10:20.000
To be coffee or something of this one.
00:10:22.000
Yes, it's in fact today the most important plantation are soybeans and sugar canes and bio-diseo.
00:10:33.000
Biodeas, yes.
00:10:35.000
And for example, the seahad place that is our savannah.
00:10:41.000
Yeah, in fact you brought me a visual map here which I'd like you to maybe say something about what you call the echo regions or the biomes of Brazil.
00:10:52.000
Because I'm not sure that many people are aware of just how diverse are these bio regions because we think of the Amazon as the dominant, but they're actually several of them.
00:11:04.000
Perfectly. So what we call biome or echo region in Brazil we have Amazonia and 60% of Amazonia belongs to Brazil territory.
00:11:18.000
Okay.
00:11:19.000
And we have the biome name in seahad, do.
00:11:23.000
And the seahado is our savannah and the seahado is a very rich place of biodiversity of animals and birds and plants.
00:11:36.000
But it's almost destruct by almost 60% destruct and only 1% is still protect.
00:11:50.000
Only 1% is protected.
00:11:52.000
And where is it in Brazil, the savannah biome, is it south of the Amazon?
00:11:59.000
Yes, exactly. It's the central Brazil.
00:12:02.000
Central Brazil.
00:12:03.000
Yeah.
00:12:04.000
Exactly the central Brazil where for example the city of Brasilia, our capital was constructed and inaugurated in 1960s.
00:12:12.000
Okay.
00:12:13.000
And the seahado and the north we have the kachinga and kachinga the name is a two-piname that means white woods because it's our semi-arid, our desert.
00:12:28.000
Okay.
00:12:29.000
Okay.
00:12:29.000
And white woods because the trees lost their leaves.
00:12:34.000
Okay.
00:12:35.000
And the other very, very important biome in Brazil is the Atlantic Forest.
00:12:42.000
The Atlantic Forest only remains 7%.
00:12:46.000
What is the Atlantic Forest?
00:12:48.000
The Atlantic Forest is the forest we found along the coast of Brazil where the cities were constructed.
00:12:57.000
So 70% of Brazilian leaves along the Atlantic Forest in the coast.
00:13:04.000
And Atlantic Forest, what we name matter, at the land chicken, is so important as Amazon.
00:13:11.000
In terms of the diversity we found in a little space, we can found 400 species of plants.
00:13:25.000
So it's incredible.
00:13:27.000
And only remains 7%.
00:13:29.000
But even this 7% is strongly important.
00:13:35.000
And another bioma is the Pantanau, is the water land.
00:13:43.000
And as in Florida we have here the...
00:13:46.000
Yeah, we call them wetlands.
00:13:47.000
Wetlands, wetlands.
00:13:49.000
Very, very important.
00:13:51.000
So with this we can understand the diversity of the forest.
00:13:55.000
So it's quite extraordinary because of this mixture of environments and biomes, eco regions.
00:14:02.000
Would you say that there's something comparable in the people of Brazil in terms of miscegenation or admixture?
00:14:13.000
Yeah.
00:14:14.000
Ethnically, culturally, racially and so forth.
00:14:17.000
Oh, absolutely.
00:14:19.000
There is nowadays a very strong discussion about affirmative action in Brazil and affirmative action in the universities.
00:14:31.000
Because we are people that always represent ourselves are mixed-reses.
00:14:39.000
A mixed-reses between white, Indians and blacks.
00:14:45.000
And we have a very new ones' terms to describe each blend, each mixture.
00:14:52.000
So for example, between white and black, we have Cabo Clue, we have Mamilouco, we have Caffusu,
00:15:00.000
and so forth.
00:15:03.000
So diverse name is to describe our mix.
00:15:08.000
It brings something to my mind about the fact that in English for example we have one word for snow and the Eskimos or other people who inhabit the northern regions might have 20 words for what we see as only one phenomenon.
00:15:21.000
Yeah, so that's nuance also.
00:15:23.000
So we're agreeing that nuance has something to do with admixture, blending, gradation.
00:15:29.000
Yes, variation.
00:15:31.000
And variation.
00:15:32.000
Yeah.
00:15:33.000
So are there any other characteristics about Brazil?
00:15:36.000
We've talked about the geography and the population.
00:15:41.000
That also makes it particularly hospitable to the phenomenon of nuance in the cultural mentality, for example, when the French used to call East-Wad de Montalite.
00:15:54.000
I think maybe we can speak about music, Brazilian music.
00:16:02.000
It's our, I think that mostly of our mentality was expressed in music in songs and lyrics.
00:16:11.000
And we can remember, for example, the blend produced by Bosanova movement.
00:16:18.000
And between Samba, popular song, Brazilian popular song, blended with cool jazz and classical music.
00:16:29.000
And this very, I think it's important song, because it's very nuanced.
00:16:35.000
The instrumentalization and the way to sing.
00:16:39.000
It's very loose.
00:16:41.000
It's very sweet, very calm.
00:16:44.000
And it's a kind of gift that Brazil offered to the world.
00:16:50.000
And it's success, proved that.
00:16:53.000
Along with a fabulous style of playing soccer, which I think is many people around the world love to watch Brazilian soccer.
00:17:00.000
Because if we can speak about nuance in soccer, it's definitely the Brazilian team that has that.
00:17:05.000
You brought some examples of Brazilian music and also Bosanova.
00:17:10.000
Yes.
00:17:11.000
Maybe we could play.
00:17:12.000
Yes.
00:17:13.000
Of course.
00:17:14.000
Just one comment about football.
00:17:17.000
Yes.
00:17:18.000
Because we are talking about the struggle between diversity as nuance, variations and monocultures in Brazil today in terms of geography.
00:17:31.000
And it's true.
00:17:33.000
So our friends have converged nose better than I, for example, that Brazilian football today has lost some of its nuance.
00:17:47.000
And so I think that balance between nuance and the loss of nuances is important in Brazil even for football.
00:17:57.000
I agree with you.
00:17:58.000
In fact, we're talking about Brazil today, but obviously our topic about nuance and the threat to nuance, diversity and miscegination.
00:18:08.000
All this has a global extension in the threat that is posed by monocultralization, not only in the sphere of agriculture, but also in the cultural sphere, might be associated with Americanization or Westernization or the reduction of diversity of the sameness is something that
00:18:27.000
people and cultures, the world around are facing.
00:18:31.000
Perfectly.
00:18:33.000
But yes, we can hear the song about the song.
00:18:37.000
What did you bring exactly?
00:18:39.000
I brought the song written by Tom Jobeen.
00:18:43.000
Tom Jobeen is our musician and magician.
00:18:47.000
And he died some years ago.
00:18:50.000
And he was the proponent, Prince Pro-Pro-Pro-Peneant of Bosanova together with Jon Jobeer to and
00:18:56.000
the Vinisou Jimoris.
00:18:58.000
But this song, precisely this song is a song brought in the 1980s when Tom Jobeen was fighting for ecology.
00:19:10.000
And the name of this song is Passarin.
00:19:13.000
Passarin is an effective way to talk about birds.
00:19:18.000
And one of the diversity we found in Brazil is an enormous varieties of birds.
00:19:28.000
And so this song speaks about the fire in the woods, in the forest.
00:19:36.000
And he tries to say little bird, light away because the forest will take fire.
00:19:46.000
And my love too and feeling the happiness and everything.
00:19:52.000
So we'll give it a listen.
00:19:54.000
Maybe we won't get through the whole song, but we'll listen certainly to part of it now.
00:19:57.000
Okay.
00:19:58.000
[Music]
00:20:08.000
[Music]
00:20:18.000
[Music]
00:20:22.000
[Music]
00:20:28.000
[Music]
00:20:38.000
[Music]
00:20:48.000
[Music]
00:20:58.000
[Music]
00:21:06.000
[Music]
00:21:16.000
[Music]
00:21:26.000
[Music]
00:21:34.000
[Music]
00:21:52.000
So Marilia, Passanova, what is it exactly?
00:21:56.000
I mean, this is an example of Passanova, I suppose.
00:21:58.000
Yes, yes, yes. So it's this written me totally related to the lyrics and this kind of instrumentation.
00:22:10.000
And this is Passanova, the new bit created, in fact, it created the historical moment of Passanova
00:22:18.000
was the end of the 1950s. And that song, it's after that historical moment, but it's still
00:22:26.000
in the end of the
00:22:26.840
And New Orleans place, obviously it is a musical genre that's based on New Orleans now.
00:22:34.000
Yeah, yeah, exactly. Because it's full of gradation and I think that sweetness, that the
00:22:42.800
de-cerate, it's very nuanced, it's produced by New Orleans, it's not something that I think
00:22:49.120
like rock, music.
00:22:52.000
It's not like the kind of Passanova that you can get from Western style music, which borrows
00:23:00.000
the Passanova and gives a very kind of a nuanced version of it, like the following.
00:23:06.000
[Music]
00:23:34.000
[Music]
00:23:50.000
That's just to give you a contrast of what's going on.
00:23:53.000
Non-new on, so Passanova is all about good. So what is this exactly?
00:24:00.000
This is a live performance of Break on Through to the Other Side by The Doors. Oh, okay.
00:24:06.000
The listeners of this show know that I have a particular sort of affection for The Doors, the General.
00:24:14.000
Me too, yeah.
00:24:15.000
And it's true that they have an extraordinary drummer, John Densmore, who took a song which should have had a completely different kind of beat, a more standard rock beat.
00:24:25.000
And he borrowed the, you know, what the Americans call the Passanova, the Passanova beat, and gave it something to that song which does add an element of nuance, believe it or not, into what would have otherwise been maybe of more straightforward and banal kind of rock song.
00:24:42.000
Yeah, good.
00:24:45.000
And I presume that there's many different kinds of music, the same way there are very different kinds of biomes and Brazil, very different kinds of musical genres.
00:24:55.000
Oh, of course. Oh, yeah, it's even the hip hop and the Brazilian rock and many nuances of the kind of samba, samba, camsang, shuru, and many different rhythms and music and
00:25:13.000
music and Brazil, it's very stronger by its music.
00:25:19.000
And before we go on to talk about Brazilian literature, maybe we could hear one more thing that you brought in, which is a very different musical genre, I believe.
00:25:28.000
Yeah, it's exactly.
00:25:29.000
I brought music collected by composer named Martin Wyme Randa in the Ama Parr region in the north of Amazonia.
00:25:42.000
And the frontier with Guiana, it's an Indian who is singing and it's the kind of song produced in the forest by what we call shamans.
00:25:56.000
And you know, to enter the forest, Indian tribes, it's a ritual. We respect a lot this environment of the forest.
00:26:09.000
And that song precisely is related to the morning time.
00:26:15.000
And it's beautiful because it's come together with modern orchestration, with a piano together with the traditional Indian song.
00:26:28.000
[Music]
00:26:57.000
[Music]
00:27:26.000
[Music]
00:27:55.000
[Music]
00:28:24.000
[Music]
00:28:53.000
[Music]
00:29:22.000
[Music]
00:29:51.000
[Music]
00:30:20.000
[Music]
00:30:49.000
[Music]
00:31:18.000
[Music]
00:31:47.000
[Music]
00:32:16.000
[Music]
00:32:45.000
[Music]
00:33:14.000
[Music]
00:33:43.000
[Music]
00:34:12.000
[Music]
00:34:41.000
[Music]
00:35:10.000
[Music]
00:35:39.000
[Music]
00:36:08.000
[Music]
00:36:37.000
[Music]
00:37:06.000
[Music]
00:37:35.000
[Music]
00:38:04.000
[Music]
00:38:33.000
[Music]
00:39:02.000
[Music]
00:39:31.000
[Music]
00:40:00.000
[Music]
00:40:29.000
[Music]
00:40:58.000
[Music]
00:41:27.000
[Music]
00:41:56.000
[Music]
00:42:25.000
[Music]
00:42:54.000
[Music]
00:43:23.000
[Music]
00:43:52.000
[Music]
00:44:21.000
[Music]
00:44:50.000
[Music]
00:45:19.000
[Music]
00:45:48.000
[Music]
00:46:17.000
[Music]
00:46:46.000
[Music]
00:47:15.000
[Music]
00:47:44.000
[Music]
00:48:13.000
[Music]
00:48:42.000
[Music]
00:49:11.000
[Music]
00:49:40.000
[Music]
00:50:09.000
[Music]
00:50:38.000
[Music]
00:51:07.000
[Music]
00:51:36.000
[Music]
00:52:05.000
[Music]
00:52:34.000
[Music]
00:53:03.000
[Music]
00:53:32.000
[Music]
00:54:01.000
[Music]
00:54:30.000
[Music]
00:54:59.000
[Music]
00:55:28.000
[Music]
00:55:57.000
[Music]
00:56:26.000
[Music]
00:56:55.000
[Music]