table of contents

01/18/2022

California Writers Part 1

Scott Thomas Anderson is a journalist whose work regularly appears in The San Francisco Chronicle and The Sacramento News & Review. He studied American Literature at the University of California at Davis, and while the bulk of his 15-year career has been primarily as a crime reporter, he’s recently started to balance that focus by […]

download transcript [vtt]
00:00:00.000
[Music]
00:00:16.480
This is KZSU Stanford.
00:00:18.480
[Music]
00:00:21.120
Welcome to entitled opinions. My name is Robert Harrison,
00:00:24.640
and we're coming to you from the Stanford campus.
00:00:27.040
[Music]
00:00:31.840
That's right, coming to you from the Stanford campus.
00:00:35.040
After two years of wandering the COVID night,
00:00:38.160
we're back in the bunker of KZSU for the very first time,
00:00:42.400
back in the throbbing incubator of our studio B,
00:00:46.160
where we breed, brood, beget, and blast out ideas for the entitled opinions brigade.
00:00:54.160
For you the thoughtful ones, you the undergrounders,
00:00:58.320
you whom comrade Nietzsche called an overture and it going under,
00:01:03.120
a bridge and not an end. I love those who do not know how to live,
00:01:08.000
except by going under, where they are the ones who cross over,
00:01:12.000
thus spoke their through strip. I love the great despisers because they are the great
00:01:18.080
reverers and arrows of longing for the other shore. I love him who lives to know and who wants to know.
00:01:25.680
I love him who makes his virtue, his addiction, and his catastrophe.
00:01:30.720
I love him who does not want to have too many virtues.
00:01:34.560
One virtue is more virtue than two because it is more of a news on which his catastrophe may hang.
00:01:43.200
I love him who has a free spirit and a free heart, thus his head is only the
00:01:48.320
entrails of his heart, but his heart drives him to go under.
00:01:52.400
Thus spoke zero through strip and thus speaks your hosts from the underworld of KZSU,
00:01:59.040
where we keep the conversation going with all unites from the order of entitled opinions.
00:02:13.040
[Music]
00:02:23.040
[Music]
00:02:43.040
KZSU located at the western edge of the western world,
00:02:50.000
otherwise known as California. It's here that the sun goes under in order to cross over.
00:02:56.720
It's from here that we fling our arrows of longing for the other shore, even if there is no
00:03:02.960
other shore. California, a golden gate to nowhere, a bridge that stretches out in
00:03:10.080
transcendence only to plunge into the abyss. Get here and we'll do the rest.
00:03:16.240
California dreaming, that's the news we hang, our catastrophe on. As Frank Zappa put it,
00:03:22.720
if we'd all been living in California, none of this would have happened.
00:03:26.080
Well, we all got here from elsewhere, eager for the beginning of the end of the affair.
00:03:32.240
[Music]
00:03:44.240
[Music]
00:04:12.560
Speaking of California, our show today is devoted to some of the early writers and journalists who made
00:04:20.480
their way to this lawless land in the 19th century and found a voice for themselves that led to
00:04:27.520
the beginnings of a California literary style. The guest who joins me today has been studying
00:04:34.160
these trail blazers. Scott Thomas Anderson studied American literature before becoming a journalist.
00:04:41.840
A very interesting journalist at that, he writes for the San Francisco Chronicle and the Sacramento news
00:04:48.320
and review. For the past 15 years, he's worked primarily as a crime reporter, and one day I'd
00:04:55.680
like to do a show with him about crime, law enforcement, and California politics. But today,
00:05:02.960
he joins me to talk about his other main interests, namely literature, culture, and travel.
00:05:09.680
Recently, Scott Anderson has been writing and producing a documentary podcast series that takes
00:05:15.680
him to various cities around the world to study the link between drinking cultures and creative
00:05:22.000
legacies. He calls his series "Drinkers with Writing Problems." Season 1, which includes episodes
00:05:30.320
written and recorded in Ireland, Scotland, Spain, New Orleans, and Hollywood, is currently available
00:05:37.440
on most podcast platforms. The premiere of season 2, which features an episode about writers
00:05:44.160
during the California gold rush, premieres on January 20th, 2022. And that, as it happens, is the
00:05:52.640
topic of our show today, Scott Thomas Anderson, welcome to the program. Thank you, great to be here.
00:05:59.040
Let me mention that you not only listen to entitled opinions, but you also published a feature
00:06:04.400
article about this radio show in the San Francisco Chronicle. It came out a few weeks ago, I think the title
00:06:10.720
was an intellectual dig through past plagues and future texts. And it's available for free online
00:06:17.680
for those listeners who may be interested in reading. It's a great piece, I have to say.
00:06:23.440
Thank you for bringing some attention to entitled opinions in the Bay Area.
00:06:29.280
We're an underground show, as you know, and a little photophobic, but it can't hurt every now and then
00:06:35.120
to shine a light on what we do down here in the catacombs of Gaze-Y issue. In any case, it was when you
00:06:41.600
contacted me about that article that I came to learn of your project about California writers
00:06:47.200
during the gold rush. It's a really interesting subject, and we're going to turn to it momentarily.
00:06:52.560
But first, maybe you could tell us something about this documentary you're producing,
00:06:56.800
drinkers with writing problems. Yeah, I guess it started as an attempt to bring a little bit of
00:07:04.160
balance to my professional life, my mindset, in that the first decade of my career was so intensely
00:07:15.840
focused on being a police reporter, trying to be the kind of crime journalist that took
00:07:22.160
readers in very deep on complex homicides and investigations into the drug world and all the tragedy
00:07:31.360
that darkens that world. The kind of reporter, someone like Alfredo Corchado was when I was coming up,
00:07:38.480
and I dedicated so much of my energy to that. And then about 10 years in, I started to realize that
00:07:47.920
it's not entirely healthy for one to dedicate their whole creative core to those things.
00:07:54.400
So I am still a police reporter part-time, but I've branched out into also writing about
00:08:03.120
literary topics, travel journalism,
00:08:06.640
appreciations of beer, wine, and spirits. So this documentary podcast series was an outgrowth
00:08:14.880
of all that transition. Combined with this question that would come up sometimes when I'd go to
00:08:20.640
the bar with other reporters, you know, I'd get these stolen moments with the tattered remnants
00:08:26.480
of my tribe and in conversation, it would often come up that our favorite reporters, our favorite
00:08:31.920
journalists, in fact, oftentimes our favorite writers, were all drinkers. So it got me thinking,
00:08:41.200
what does that say about the creative process? What does that say about the life-coping process?
00:08:47.280
What does that say about the specific cultures that these individuals were speaking for?
00:08:52.880
And speaking too. So with this podcast documentary series, I basically go to places where these
00:09:04.640
writers haunted and I try to follow in their footsteps. I drink the things they drank. I'm trying to
00:09:11.680
explore the lives of these writers and use what they drank, the drinking culture they were part of.
00:09:17.360
It's just kind of a window to look at the broader creative culture of the cities and places that
00:09:23.600
produce them. And woven in with that are interviews with contemporary writers who live in those places,
00:09:31.360
distillers, bar tenders, wine makers, independent bookstore owners, anybody who can sort of help me
00:09:39.600
explore that question. What do you learn from those visits to bars and speaking to bar tenders and
00:09:47.440
others about the writers at least the creative process of writing? It's very interesting in the
00:09:54.720
sense that it's so different with different writers and the overarching question of how many of
00:10:01.440
these writers were actually alcoholics and how many of them were just recreational drinkers and how
00:10:08.160
much gray area there is between those two things with some of these writers. It seems to me it's
00:10:13.360
different with every writer whose life I explore. I don't personally make a blanket statement like
00:10:20.000
some folks do about this topic. I got the name of this series, "Drinkers with Writing Problems." It's
00:10:28.800
from a quote often attributed to the great Irish novelist and playwright Brendan B.N.
00:10:33.760
So the very first episode I did, the first half of it was written and recorded in Dublin and
00:10:39.440
it was the first half is about him. And with him because he used the Irish drinking culture,
00:10:48.960
the Irish love of pubs and the Irish storytelling tradition and that grew up in those pubs. It was
00:10:57.840
so much part of his persona as a writer. He was a great self-marketer. And so it was very easy on
00:11:07.040
the research and to go to a bunch of pubs that still looked the same as when he was in them in the
00:11:13.120
1940s and '50s and '60s. And some of those pubs are pictures of him on the wall.
00:11:19.920
On the research end, that was one of the more easy writers to handle with this topic. And some of
00:11:28.160
the others, it's taken a ton of research to really have confidence to say not only what they
00:11:34.640
drank and where they drank and sort of if that affected them at all in terms of their creative
00:11:41.920
process or not. Or if it maybe it was just part of their routine that brought them together with
00:11:48.080
people who were their support network.
00:11:50.160
I think maybe the only Irish writer or poet who was not a pub-goer and didn't get into it was
00:11:58.320
W. B. Yates. I know him anecdote where he finally in his late middle age, you know, maybe he was in his
00:12:05.120
'50s. He went to a pub for the first time at some friends and sisters. He sat there for five minutes.
00:12:11.360
He says, "I've been to a pub now. Can we leave?" So not very Irish in that regard as you know.
00:12:17.200
So we're going to talk about the California part that season two. But how about keeping our listeners a
00:12:24.960
sense of some of the writers that you deal with in season one?
00:12:28.160
Yeah. Season one, the first episode is, as I said, written in half the first house written and
00:12:34.240
recorded in Dublin in the second half is written and recorded in Belfast. And in the second half,
00:12:39.280
I actually really focused that on contemporary writers who are there right now, who grew up
00:12:45.040
during the troubles and have channeled their childhood memories of essentially an urban civil war
00:12:52.320
into their fiction. And the pub culture of Belfast plays a very intriguing role in many of their books
00:13:02.480
because there are segregated pubs and then there are also a few pubs in the city center, these
00:13:08.960
old beautiful Victorian gin palaces where both Catholics and Protestants would drink together.
00:13:16.080
So that makes for a very crucial setting for some of these scenes in their novels. The second
00:13:22.880
episode was written and recorded in Scotland and it's partly about Robert Louis Stevenson and it's
00:13:31.600
partly about the work George Orwell did when he was out living in isolation in the Hebrides as
00:13:38.240
he wrote 1984. And of course he wrote that in next to the greatest whiskey making island in the world,
00:13:46.160
some would say. And his letter is at the time he actually complained that he was surrounded by all
00:13:56.000
these magnificence, Scotch distilleries, but he couldn't get a bottle himself because it was all
00:14:00.640
being shipped to America. It was just one of many, many complaints he had about the United States,
00:14:07.520
but he comes up in his letters. How many episodes in season one, five episodes? Five episodes.
00:14:13.840
Yeah. I believe you also went to the Lake District. That'll be in season two. In season two,
00:14:19.440
okay. So let's move to season two because our topic today is about the California gold rush,
00:14:24.880
the 19th century and writers who were also journalists very interestingly, we're going to talk
00:14:32.160
about the 19th century and maybe in a follow-up show we can talk about the 20th century, but we're
00:14:36.640
here really to talk about what happened in the 1800s and there are a number of protagonists,
00:14:45.040
but we're going to have to kind of keep it just a handful of them and we might want to start with
00:14:51.680
who should we start with? I say we start with John Rallenridge who in his day, during the California
00:14:59.760
gold rush was one of the best known writers, if not the best known writer in California.
00:15:04.720
And he's so, you know, in the term Shakespearean is so overused these days, particularly by people in
00:15:14.080
my profession who are writing on a deadline, but with John Rallenridge, his story is so uniquely
00:15:20.560
American that he might be that rare case where it's a fitting title. John Rallenridge was a Cherokee man
00:15:28.960
who was born in the heart of the Cherokee nation in northern Georgia in the 1830s and he was the
00:15:35.920
grandson of a legendary Cherokee leader named Major Ridge and this was somebody who had sort of in his
00:15:43.920
younger days fought a war with the invading frontiers people and was such a formidable opponent that
00:15:52.880
US forces wanted him and his tribe as an ally in the grand scheme of things and so the Cherokee were
00:16:01.840
an ally to the United States army during the creek wars and his grandfather Major Ridge became a very
00:16:07.440
famous military commander in that conflict and what essentially happened was Andrew Jackson
00:16:16.560
betrayed his grandfather, betrayed the Cherokee people and despite all these things they had done
00:16:24.720
for him militarily, he turned around and supported the state of Georgia in stripping the Cherokee
00:16:30.800
people of their lands and forcing what has become known as the Trail of Tears and when they were
00:16:38.080
all relocated to Arkansas to what they called the new Cherokee territory, there was an inner tribal
00:16:45.920
conflict kind of a soft tribal civil war that erupted and John Rallenridge was only a little boy
00:16:53.200
at the time but his whole family was killed in that conflict. All the almost all the men in his
00:16:59.680
family were killed by other Cherokees, by other Cherokee and so as he grew into a teenager and a young
00:17:07.520
man this conflict continued that conflict continued right into the American Civil War with one
00:17:12.960
faction of the Cherokee signing one way and the other signing the other as he grew into a young
00:17:18.560
man he was pulled into the violence between the tribes and he ended up having to flee and this was
00:17:24.880
right when goal was discovered in California so the obvious escape route was to build a new life in
00:17:31.600
this land of new possibility and he came out to California to the gold fields in 1849. I think it
00:17:36.960
actually arrived in 1850, set out in 1849 when goal was discovered like everyone had to cross the
00:17:42.800
whole continent to get out here arrives in 1850. He eventually became a very prominent journalist all
00:17:52.480
around northern California, he worked for numerous newspapers, he was the founding editor of the
00:17:57.280
Sacramento Bee which still exists to this day, he was the founding editor, one of the newspapers
00:18:02.320
that still exist in Mary'sville and he ended up in grass valley which was a booming mining town
00:18:09.680
and he had a newspaper there called the Grass Valley National and the reason he is so unique is because
00:18:17.360
not only was he the first Native American writer to become nationally famous writing in English
00:18:24.160
he also wrote the very first hit book in California history which is a book called The Life and
00:18:30.960
Times of the Celebrated Bandit, What Cane, Marietta and for your listeners who may not have heard
00:18:38.880
that name before, What Cane, Marietta was a name that was attributed to essentially a mass crime wave that
00:18:47.120
happened during the gold rush between around 1849 and 1853 where there were incidents of bandits and
00:18:59.600
sort of highwaymen committing crimes all over the state and somehow the newspapers sort of coalesced
00:19:07.600
all these different events into the idea of a single outlaw that was committing them and that
00:19:15.120
exactly what Vico calls a poetic character. Yes. The second individual personification of a larger community.
00:19:21.360
Yes and so it was believed in the camps that all of these crimes were being committed by an outlaw
00:19:29.200
named What Cane, Marietta. In the documentary I'm working on you will hear Gary Noi who's the most
00:19:37.040
eminent historian writing today for the California gold rush really breaks down all the different
00:19:43.600
factors that led into people believing that one man could be responsible for all these crimes.
00:19:48.880
But nevertheless there was a belief that this outlaw, What Cane, Marietta, was everywhere.
00:19:55.760
He was in Southern California one day killing somebody. He was in Northern California a week later
00:20:02.160
killing three people and essentially there was a kind of hysteria set in in the gold mining camps.
00:20:09.280
Some of the miners had been very abusive to not only the indigenous people here in California but
00:20:15.760
also the California, the Mexican California culture that was already here before the gold rush.
00:20:21.200
And the idea that someone from that community would be seeking revenge was a terrifying thought to
00:20:27.360
a lot of these miners because even if they hadn't been involved in the abuses they certainly
00:20:31.440
had many of them had seen those abuses many of them were aware of those abuses. So it was not
00:20:37.360
unlike the kind of fear that was in the deep south of a slave revolt when people understand what kind of
00:20:44.240
harm has been afflicted on a community and then suddenly there's an idea that somebody would come
00:20:48.880
seek retribution. So the California government one of the first things it did was put a death warrant
00:20:55.520
out on walk in Marietta, whoever he was. And a group of former Texas Rangers calling themselves
00:21:02.800
the California Rangers went out and hunted down a group of men and killed them and brought back
00:21:09.920
a head pickled in a whiskey jar that they said belonged to walk in Marietta and they were
00:21:16.080
parading this head around from town to town. John Rowland Ridge was a reporter a crime
00:21:20.640
he was well he was sort of a general assignment reporter while all this was happening.
00:21:26.400
John Rowland Ridge he did sort of believe this idea that that walking Marietta was a person who had
00:21:34.240
maybe done all these things but he became obsessed with the story and he traveled from town to town
00:21:39.600
through all the different gold mining camps and all the different boom towns that walking
00:21:43.440
it's supposedly done things and he collected all these stories and he published them just
00:21:51.520
Well about two years after the head appeared in the jar John Rowland Ridge published this book
00:21:57.280
The Life and Times of the Celebrated Bandit Walking Marietta and what was so
00:22:01.280
thematically unique about the book is Ridge portrayed Marietta as a romantic figure as a
00:22:11.120
Avenger of and and well the term that came up after the book was published was the Robin
00:22:19.200
Hood of the West or the Robin Hood of the Goldfields Robin Hood of the Mother loads. Ridge
00:22:24.720
portrayed him as kind of a the gold country's version of the Count of Monte Cristo and in the
00:22:31.040
documentary Gary Noi talks about the parallels between ridges on life in this story he created
00:22:37.680
around a bandit who you know I who may or may not have been a real person. It may not have been
00:22:45.680
a real person but out of curiosity there were real events of attacks on the gold miners and other.
00:22:54.240
Yeah the crime wave was a real and I think actually there is some evidence that there that one
00:23:01.680
individual involved in the crime wave may have been named walking Marietta but there were
00:23:06.640
five to six other people in different parts of the states that were the state that were part of
00:23:11.440
the crime wave some of whom also had the first name of Joaquin but they had different last names
00:23:16.640
well whose head ended up in the whiskey jars are really tough not to crack but John
00:23:24.640
Rallen Ridge published this book and it was a massive success it was so successful it made it
00:23:29.920
made establishes reputation all through California and it made its way out east and he became
00:23:36.640
he became a famous writer despite all the prejudices of the day that were aimed at indigenous people
00:23:43.200
he really overcame it so he becomes famous and he continues his work as a journalist.
00:23:48.880
Yeah one thing I really wanted to clue in the documentary is he never forgot what happened to his
00:23:56.400
family and this whole time he was a sort of building fame and reputation and what in his mind
00:24:04.800
he would have called respectability and mainstream society which was not easy for indigenous people
00:24:09.840
at that time the whole time he was secretly plotting revenge against the people who had killed his
00:24:15.600
family and one really interesting thing about John Rallen Ridge is in terms of American writers
00:24:21.920
he's such a product of the West in the sense that I can sit here and say that he was this
00:24:31.040
pathfinding literary figure who really deserves to be revisited and to come out of the veil
00:24:38.000
at the same time I would also say he Ridge was a guy that today we would say he was just barely
00:24:44.880
keeping a lid on a piping volcano top of PTSD he had witnessed some acts of violence as a child
00:24:53.600
that would boggle our own minds and it's not surprising that he himself grew up to be a violent man
00:25:00.720
and it's very much like other western figures of of his era the earth brothers Bill Hyekok
00:25:08.880
people like that Ridge was not a man you wanted to cross at all he was a violent person
00:25:15.120
despite being a famous writer so he gets into trouble I think as a result of his attempts to
00:25:23.840
take revenge for the people who had assassinated his father and massacred the whole reason he came out
00:25:32.880
to the gold rushes he had killed someone in the Arkansas territory that was peripherally
00:25:39.040
connected to his family's murder the documentary gets into the details of how that went down
00:25:45.280
whether it was self-defence or not that he did always claim it was self-defence but when he
00:25:52.240
when he rose to prominent prominence in california one of i think one of the issues that's
00:25:57.120
come up why he he's not better remembered and why there's not more of an effort to remember him
00:26:01.760
now in california is while being really immersed in his Cherokee culture and very prideful of his
00:26:09.360
Cherokee culture he was also a southerner and he had very complicated politics when the civil
00:26:16.560
war erupted and that was true all through the all through the gold country in california most towns
00:26:24.160
ended up having two different newspapers one would be sort of a pro union newspaper and one
00:26:30.080
would be a confederate sympathizing if not pro confederate newspaper ridge wasn't
00:26:35.440
fully pro confederate during the civil war but he was way more sympathetic to the southern plight
00:26:43.760
than most people were comfortable with in the mining towns and that did affect his reputation in a
00:26:49.920
really negative way and it led him to numerous physical challenges and altercations with different
00:26:57.040
people to the point where he challenged people to gunfights in the street he he assaulted another
00:27:03.920
newspaper publisher so that's what i mean he what he he having gone through what he went through
00:27:09.680
having seen when he saw as a child having that kind of horror ingrained in his mind
00:27:15.280
he was a violent man throughout his life yeah what do you make of his literary uh
00:27:20.240
virtues that's a really interesting question because i think you if when you read the celebrated
00:27:29.360
bandit while kane marietta when you read that book it's very important to remember
00:27:35.920
that john rolin ridge was he was educated in a time when most native people were not given the
00:27:42.640
opportunity to be educated he was educated educated by missionaries and his literate his own
00:27:48.160
literary tastes were what was popular when he was young uh the romantic british romantic poets
00:27:54.400
john kites percy shellley lord biren words were and and people who would coming up in his own life
00:28:03.440
long fellow you know so he was very consciously i think trying to show that he could master that
00:28:11.120
style of writing and there are some beautiful passages in the book about kane marietta it's just
00:28:18.000
some a couple passages that are just beautiful descriptions of what california look like when it
00:28:22.880
was completely untamed when it was completely unspoiled before the industrial gold mines came in
00:28:28.480
when there were just mining camps but before these giant industrial sort of mills came in
00:28:33.200
so he was a talented writer today he's he's only really lives in the in the literary can
00:28:42.320
in for one poem called mount chasta so it's very rare to find any kind of a thology from
00:28:48.640
norton or anyone else that would have him in it outside of that one poem mount chasta but if you
00:28:54.240
read that poem you will see the influence of of percy shell and john kites i think if you if you read
00:28:59.120
that poem i think what ridges problem was as a writer is he was mastering a style and uh and
00:29:08.080
showing that he could master that style in california essentially eight or nine years before
00:29:13.680
this young man named mark twain showed up in the scene and and destroyed that style and just shattered
00:29:18.960
and i do think that played a role in ridges sort of retreating as a writer into the shadows is
00:29:25.600
these other writers that were a little younger than him mark twain and emberos beer specifically
00:29:31.360
were sort of reinventing not only california literature but just they were really pushing american
00:29:38.800
literature in a new direction yeah i want to talk about some of those characters but um one last
00:29:46.320
question about rigid do you get a real sense of the california land
00:29:51.040
when you read them i mean i'm i'm i ask out of total ignorance and not having you know red
00:29:56.480
red and at all so i i'm curious about yeah i do what kind of california is it a pyro disal
00:30:03.200
kind of he's he seems to have sought that way he wrote about it that way he wrote about it as as a
00:30:11.120
this vast um mountainous in some places pastoral and others but just this beautiful land that had
00:30:20.000
all these different types of landscape but he wrote about it with a sense that there was freedom
00:30:26.240
everywhere you went and um i don't know if it was having grown up with all of these conflicts around
00:30:35.120
land you know having been forcibly removed from land as a child and having all these
00:30:40.400
violent conflicts about lands that he grew up with as a teenager but i wonder if when he got out
00:30:47.600
here just the vast openness and of the land and and it was so unclaimed i think that really
00:30:55.600
comes through in his writing and it's probably the highlights of that story i mean it's a fun story
00:31:00.720
to read uh just if you like bandit tails i mean it's basically one big series of tall tails around
00:31:07.520
a bandit it can be fun to read but what would you actually take away from it the beauty of of the
00:31:13.920
land yeah and his journalism quickly was he was a very versatile journalist uh he wrote a you know
00:31:21.440
the journalists of that era especially if they were like rich and they hunker down in one town and
00:31:28.000
really made a stake there for years at a time they had to write about everything he was very good
00:31:32.960
about writing about crime but he wrote about politics he wrote about commerce he wrote about the
00:31:38.240
production of the mines the threat of fire something we can really relate to to this day he
00:31:44.000
grass valley suffered a catastrophic fire um and he wrote you know he his journalism covered the
00:31:51.040
aftermath of that was he a drinker he was and he's been it's been very very
00:31:57.600
difficult for me to say exactly what he drank because again we have to go back to the the context
00:32:06.560
he's writing in he's becoming essentially the first famous indigenous writer in america
00:32:13.280
i believe he was very conscious to the kind of unfair stereotypes that were floating around so yes
00:32:21.840
he did drink but he was not a writer who wrote about what he drank he was for obvious reasons trying
00:32:29.680
to present a very respectable or the words he would have used honorable image but yes he did drink
00:32:37.600
what he drank whatever they were pouring you know in the bars and saloons that he was in yeah
00:32:44.480
you mentioned mark twang but also embro's beer say i'm interested in embro's beer
00:32:50.800
because we know less about him most people know less about him than mark twang and he also journalist
00:32:58.240
writer poet yeah even horror the horror genre very very interesting character with it really
00:33:09.200
fascinating bio as well and he is a major protagonist i guess in your season too uh not so much in the
00:33:17.600
season but i did a big feature on him for the san francisco chronicle recently and that whole
00:33:23.840
first class of california writers they all came up through newspaper work in the in the camps and
00:33:33.280
in the boom towns who is john rallen ridge a young mark twang embro's beer's bread heart
00:33:42.000
all four of them were formed in the newspaper world and they all start out working in for
00:33:50.720
newspapers in this very chaotic atmosphere that's whiskey soaked and completely removed from the
00:33:59.120
respectable east coast establishment and it's a lawless territory and it essentially encourages
00:34:08.080
all of them to be stylistic mavericks and so yeah beer gets here right after the civil war
00:34:15.680
i like to think of embro's beers in his time as he's his 30 years in san francisco as a journalist i
00:34:23.840
like to think of him is almost a walking ghost because he should not have been alive he was a union
00:34:32.400
soldier during the civil war he survived the battle of shylo which was probably the pinnacle of
00:34:40.160
carnage in that war and then he was shot in the head while charging kennasaw mountain which was
00:34:46.720
another pivotal union victory and he i mean short shot directly in the head by all numbers and
00:34:54.000
probability he should not have survived and he comes out to california right after the war is over
00:35:02.160
a man who's nine lives were long since up when he got here and he becomes a newspaper reporter
00:35:09.440
who works for several publications but he's eventually recruited by a very young William Randolph
00:35:16.000
Hearst to be the sort of the star journalist for the san francisco examiner yeah and when you talk about
00:35:25.680
this understanding of death that he had having witnessed the worst battles of the civil war and again
00:35:33.760
having somehow climbed out of the grave himself it's it's interesting that he becomes a journalist in
00:35:40.960
san francisco with a reputation for being absolutely fearless for both crime reporting and political
00:35:48.480
reporting a writer who's known to write with a human skull on his desk that he refuses to explain
00:35:55.840
where it came from i mean he he he's he's has a dark patina to him and when you read the pieces of
00:36:03.520
literature he's most remembered for these morbid surreal but pretty beautiful stories like
00:36:10.160
an occurrence at al creek bridge or the damned thing to me that's clearly coming from a writer whose
00:36:19.040
mind has a certain intimacy with death yeah for sure he also was implicated in the assassination of
00:36:27.280
the president some in an indirect way no how does that work because he had written a poem earlier
00:36:34.400
i'm trying to recall now what i research you know well coming in today you're going to do a better
00:36:41.520
job in the me you know Ambrose beer he kind of like rich his problem is that he just happened to
00:36:49.840
be a brilliant writer at the very same moment as mark twain and so he he has again like rich he's
00:36:58.000
kind of been sort of swept away by that towering shadow of twain unlike rich beer has some pretty
00:37:04.560
strange legends that have grown up around him the assassination also his own death which
00:37:12.240
these days if you go on the internet and try to read about Ambrose beer is mostly what you're
00:37:17.520
going to get is all these theories about how he himself died which is a huge mystery yeah can you
00:37:23.360
can you tell our listeners about that because it is really very intriguing even i got
00:37:27.920
swept in so i it's believed that he was setting out to
00:37:34.640
rendezvous with poncho via and cover the mexican revolution and that he was either
00:37:43.520
killed by roadman along the way or or killed by via himself or i he killed somewhere in some
00:37:50.000
gruesome fashion in the deserts of mexico some very lonely death who unrecovered body but that
00:37:55.520
that's the legend that sort of come up around it but then of course the internet and personal
00:38:01.920
sloughs there's all these other alternative theories too well there there's uh... i don't know if
00:38:08.320
it's true because it was never actually discovered but apparently hit the last letter that he wrote
00:38:13.040
was uh... to a woman friend of his and says tomorrow i take off for an unknown destination
00:38:18.160
and then the man just disappears
00:38:22.000
never found an endless speculation that's one story another story that he came back and
00:38:27.600
perhaps committed suicide in grand canyon
00:38:31.600
yeah uh... he's an important figure a lot of he was what very well known yeah and hurts himself
00:38:37.600
protected him just by having to pay a price for that no yeah so one interesting thing about
00:38:43.520
and rose bierce is he was as a journalist obsessed with the so called big four the railroad
00:38:51.600
titans who had built the transcontinental railroad these are the four families that became so
00:38:57.360
incredibly wealthy in northern california and they built all the grand victorian palaces and
00:39:03.520
san francisco and and some in sacramento and bierce that's not speak to ill of the man i think
00:39:10.480
one of them yeah founder of this university yeah and there's was not a fan and uh... right well yeah
00:39:16.240
and so there not to be a fan of yeah no and in bierce was uh... he was a journalist who was
00:39:23.760
absolutely convinced that uh... that group of men had uh... the robber barons that they didn't
00:39:32.640
that they'd essentially infected every orifice and mechanism of california government and
00:39:39.760
and he dedicated much of his career uh... he outlived most of them by the way and uh... that was not
00:39:46.240
good enough for him you know so i'd probably outlived all of them but i know he outlived three of
00:39:52.880
them and was still not done shipping away at them in the scheme of politics yeah obviously
00:40:01.840
hurts would have to protect him going after people that prominent and that powerful and that
00:40:08.320
highly regarded and it was relentless he would never let up i mean we it's not what he's remembered
00:40:14.480
for now but certainly it would have been one of the main things he was known for in his own life
00:40:20.000
now we have we really focus more on either the devil's dictionary or these really incredible
00:40:26.800
short stories he left us but i think here where we are right now but in his day he would have been
00:40:32.880
more associated as as just uh... uh... uh... a dog if not vicious political reporter
00:40:40.640
we could use one of those i think they are they and age
00:40:44.400
yeah it's uh... he was a heavy drinker i believe yeah yeah and i think that he outlived us
00:40:49.840
his two sons one of whom i think died of alcoholism yeah it so bierce is the later part of his
00:40:58.240
life and i think possibly why he didn't
00:41:04.560
sort of take many precautions uh... before he disappeared is i he was a depressed person his
00:41:10.480
his family life had had taken a tragic turn and he was just uh... one of his nicknames was
00:41:16.240
bitter bierce and um... yeah he he his life got sad towards the end and that might have played a
00:41:23.120
role in why he really didn't have many connections when he vanished yeah
00:41:28.960
scott mark twang you mentioned he's a towering giant and i guess uh... sometimes those shadows
00:41:37.760
unjustly obscure other other writers like bierce i mean if i can express an unentitled opinion
00:41:46.000
about mark twang i would take bierce some of the bierce's most beautiful stories even horror stories
00:41:52.480
over mark twang myself not that i don't admire mark twang for what he did but i think that um...
00:41:58.560
but nevertheless he figures huge on the fact california scene yeah he came out because
00:42:08.320
well he was he was a riverboat pilot on the Mississippi river when the civil war broke out and
00:42:14.320
all the river traffic was brought to a halt by the war he didn't really have any interest in
00:42:19.360
fighting in the conflict on either side so it just so happened his older brother had been appointed
00:42:25.280
to a administration position in the new territory of nevada as the as the silver boom was
00:42:34.240
starting so he first went out to nevada and he got his first newspaper job in virginia city which
00:42:41.200
is the small but really interesting town uh... in the high desert mountains um of north west nevada
00:42:47.920
very close to the california border not far from lake tahou he does a year as a reporter there
00:42:55.520
and really starts to really develop um... uninteresting style again it's really based in this
00:43:02.160
idea of complete lawlessness around him and if if if there are no rules for society where you're
00:43:08.480
living then in twains view then there's also no rules for writing with the rules don't matter
00:43:13.440
anymore he's gonna write however he wants to write and including for newspapers covering stories
00:43:18.880
about what he purported to be real events and so he was doing pretty well out there but then he
00:43:24.960
essentially pulled an elaborate prank on the whole community which caused somebody to challenge him
00:43:31.840
to a duel and uh... just as as with the war he didn't really have any interest in
00:43:38.720
being another coffin in the cemetery so he lit out of there and he uh... came to san francisco and
00:43:44.880
between san francisco and sacramental and some of the other mining camps he continued to work as a
00:43:50.080
reporter and then in angels camp he just he heard a yarn inside a bar one night and he thought
00:43:58.640
if he tweaked it just a little bit he could put a certain a glow on it and that was his short
00:44:04.800
story the celebrated jumping frog of calivorous county and well as we mentioned earlier it it just
00:44:10.640
became a national phenomenon it the way information traveled at the time it was months before he even
00:44:18.480
knew that and but it was being read all over new york and all over the east coast and
00:44:25.440
it was seen as a kind of the strange funny quirky window into what must be going out at west with
00:44:30.960
these really strange people although he's more remembered or known for tom saw you're in the
00:44:36.640
adventures of so far right right he built his national rep the start of his national reputation
00:44:42.800
with that short story he wrote out here he also had a huge newspaper scoop that became a
00:44:49.360
national story for the sacramental union newspaper around the same time as the jumping frog story
00:44:55.600
so it was his early work in navata in california that both convinced him that he didn't have to
00:45:02.560
follow rules and that that codified ideas around writing and that stylistic standards of the day
00:45:09.520
didn't mean that much to him in that he could get away with breaking all those rules that's
00:45:14.240
what he learns in california when he moves back to the east coast and gets married and sort of
00:45:20.160
stops his crazy drinking and behavior that's when he becomes sort of the the megastar of literature
00:45:26.800
would you consider him a california writer i think california is a major chapter in allowing him
00:45:37.360
to have a writing career i don't think he would have caught considerate himself a california writer
00:45:44.000
or a western writer so much as a writer who came up through the ranks in that setting
00:45:51.120
because it because his his obviously when you read his work his his childhood along the
00:45:56.720
missus hippie was probably a far more towering effect on him and what he wanted to write between
00:46:03.280
tomsoyer and huck fin and life on the missus hippie and many other stories so i mean his
00:46:08.640
his formative years in the south were you know probably more defining in the long run
00:46:14.480
so do i get it right i have an impression that for these uh... people we've been talking about
00:46:24.000
twain beers maybe even rich that journalism was just as important as literature
00:46:30.320
that it was mostly what people would have considered literature when it came out well
00:46:35.040
you know and in there's a
00:46:37.440
i think that's great
00:46:39.120
where you know journalism becomes
00:46:41.200
a queen of writing along side all the other arts of could be novels poetry and
00:46:48.560
short stories
00:46:49.680
you know getting back to that book ridge road about waltkeen marietta
00:46:53.280
that's a really interesting point in the sense that when the book came out ridge
00:47:00.160
classified it as literary journalism
00:47:03.920
today historians call it a novel
00:47:07.040
but
00:47:08.160
for the first eighty or ninety years it circulated in publication it was more thought of as
00:47:13.680
literary journalism or creative nonfiction
00:47:16.560
because ridge was a professional reporter
00:47:19.520
who stood by
00:47:21.360
the sources he'd spoken to and and he
00:47:24.560
granted he collected second and third hand accounts
00:47:28.240
that he couldn't verify that he'd woven into this narrative but nonetheless he stood by it as
00:47:34.320
he would have called it literary journalism or he would have thought of it as akin to what
00:47:39.920
Ernie piled it in world war two or what
00:47:42.000
writers like tom wolf started doing in the nineteen sixties that's how ridge kind of thought about
00:47:48.080
his book now historians today
00:47:50.800
see it differently in a sort of insist on calling it a novel
00:47:54.880
because it's so fictional eyes but it does kind of raise the question of
00:47:59.680
you know it's it's analogous to kind of some of the things on her as tomson wrote in the
00:48:04.400
you know there's an essential truth to them right but there's so much invention mixed in
00:48:09.920
how do you classify it
00:48:13.120
well there's one last figure we have time for that we don't want to leave out which is Amy
00:48:17.840
crocker
00:48:19.520
she's not necessarily a journalist but what what a character you know yeah Amy crocker um
00:48:25.520
she was very very famous in her life and she was a ground-breaking writer in a lot of respects
00:48:32.640
and i think she deserves to sort of have her i have a moment in the sun again the only because
00:48:38.160
she was so far ahead of her time we talk about writers being ahead of their time she was
00:48:43.200
really ahead of her time so she was um the daughter of eb crocker who was
00:48:50.400
the brother of charles crocker of the big four you know and eb was some people
00:48:56.640
called the big five and when they do eb crocker would be the fifth person she came from one of
00:49:02.480
she came from one of the four railroad dynasty families she grew up in sacramento as a little girl
00:49:10.800
she could it was still very much a frontier town when she was a child as she got older she really
00:49:18.000
embraced this idea of having of herself as kind of having come up as a frontier woman and now
00:49:25.760
people in her own time would have found that laughable because she was from one of the richest
00:49:30.400
families in the country but in her mind the fact that she could walk out to the water docks and
00:49:34.880
watch the river boats coming in as a child and ride a horse along the ranches and see all these
00:49:39.520
kind of drunk minor stumbling around in front of the saloons late to her she she thought
00:49:45.280
herself as a frontiers woman in some respects well not not completely misguided yeah i mean i
00:49:52.800
it would be interesting to hear what her contemporaries thought when you know when she wove that
00:49:58.240
into her persona but so she grew up in sacramento but her family of course also had huge
00:50:03.840
houses and holdings in san francisco i guess she kind of grew up in both cities and then
00:50:09.520
in the 1880s when she was in her late 20s she got embroiled in a huge public scandal
00:50:17.520
that was initially about her made stealing from her and she tried to bring her made up on
00:50:25.920
charges of stealing from her and then a bunch of people in the city of sacramento who did not like
00:50:33.920
her use this trial of the maid as a referendum on ami herself and it turned into it turned into a
00:50:41.120
tabloid fiasco where there was testimony in an open court about what a hardcore drinker ami was
00:50:47.680
for which in 1880s was somewhat scandalous for a woman from her family to be this hardcore drinker
00:50:57.600
and partier and she was someone who was not too discreetly having many many affairs and all of
00:51:04.080
this sort of started coming out in the court trial and it caused a huge what her mother thought was
00:51:13.920
an unrecoverable scandal you know it's just like a fatal wound of a scandal for the family
00:51:19.760
but it does seem to have sparked an epiphany for ami where she no longer she went from
00:51:27.120
sort of not really caring what people thought about her to really not caring what people thought about
00:51:32.480
her and then and that is the attitude she brought into her writing career to help with the rules
00:51:38.800
I guess yeah to help with the rules her first few things that were published were in newspapers
00:51:44.080
they were travel journalism but she ended up leaving sacramento after in the wake of the scandal
00:51:51.760
she spent some time in New York but she really started traveling the world because she had the
00:51:55.680
means to do so she traveled all over the world and she eventually wrote this memoir
00:52:02.320
this defiantly titled memoir called And I Do It Again and it's about her travels all over the world
00:52:12.160
her many affairs all over the world she she was really a forerunner of what would later be called
00:52:17.600
the sexual revolution you know there's there's some she was a forerunner to certain elements of
00:52:22.480
feminist writing she was a forerunner to certain you know certain elements of sexual liberation writing for
00:52:28.480
women and also her memoirs very interesting because she she's a forerunner also people like lady
00:52:35.440
Gaga and all these extravagances no yes she's showing up on an elephant writing an elephant to
00:52:40.960
a part I don't know I read yes yes she she would appear in newspapers with like a huge bow constrictor
00:52:47.520
wrapped around her or you know just she she was a master at creating celebrity around herself but
00:52:57.680
at the end of the day she was a really skillful writer her memoir stands up it's it's a good
00:53:05.120
read to this day and it's also an interesting read in the sense that she managed to capture
00:53:12.560
many parts of everywhere from the Hawaiian islands to rural parts of china and japan and india
00:53:18.560
again before industrialization came in and so she she really captures a sort of twilight around a
00:53:26.000
certain moment of the world very well in her memoir but it's fun to read because it's she's like
00:53:32.720
twain she's she's a great observer of human nature she's a satirical observer of human nature
00:53:38.720
she she had beyond progressive ideas and beliefs that for her day that she was not shy about writing
00:53:46.000
about now well I'm glad we got her in to our hour here Scott and so much more to come both in
00:53:54.640
your podcast series and perhaps in a follow-up show on the 20th century California writers but I
00:54:00.480
think you've given us a real vivid sense of the way in which where we are right now is was a
00:54:08.480
really lawless land in in his violent aspects but also they kind of created potential that was
00:54:15.280
liberated yeah by the wide open expanse and freedom that California represented in the 19th century
00:54:22.640
it was a place where people could transform themselves there was there were no rules really in your
00:54:29.440
way if you want it to become a completely different person here and ridge did that and twain did that
00:54:35.600
and beer stood that and in some respects Amy did it too and who knows maybe Scott Thomas Anderson is
00:54:43.280
doing it in his own he's as a journalist and now a documentary series producer so you just continue
00:54:49.440
that great tradition of you know creative journalism we've been speaking with Scott Thomas Anderson
00:54:58.240
for entitled opinions I'm Robert Harrison tune in next time bye bye thanks again
00:55:08.240
I've been rolling a shiny black steel jacket my been shimbing up rocks for the great highway
00:55:15.120
I live five years of my take my time over that jacket drinking my wine
00:55:26.320
I've been shipping them rocks from dawn to dawn while my right I hide my bottle in the other room
00:55:37.360
not the same better stop ballin that jacket my little five years I'm on up on my back so you're so ill easy win trust the fire day
00:56:02.160
cause there's a whole right of women I'm out of red on the street today
00:56:08.960
and a river keeps up talking but you never would it say
00:56:20.480
I'm out of red on my back I'm out of red on my back
00:56:37.920
(rock music)
00:56:40.000
- Oh no.
00:57:04.560
(rock music)
00:57:07.140
(rock music)
00:57:09.720
(rock music)
00:57:12.300
(rock music)
00:57:14.540
(rock music)
00:57:16.780
(rock music)
00:57:19.280
(rock music)
00:57:22.000
[MUSIC]
00:57:48.000
[MUSIC]
00:57:58.000
[MUSIC]