10/12/2023
Vico and Joyce
A conversation with Corey Dansereau, a PhD Candidate in Modern Thought and Literature at Stanford, about the impact of Giambattista Vico on James Joyce’s writing. Songs in this episode: “Echo” by Glass Wave, and “I Might Be Wrong” by Radiohead.
00:00:00.000 |
[Music]
|
00:00:17.000 |
Entitled opinions, not for the faint of heart,
|
00:00:20.140 |
not for the socially mediated,
|
00:00:22.380 |
not for the mimic man,
|
00:00:24.120 |
not for the self-satisfied.
|
00:00:26.720 |
Out here on the perimeter, we crush on the unknown.
|
00:00:30.600 |
Out here we look out and realize we don't really know much of anything,
|
00:00:35.960 |
beyond the sheer weirdness of whatever we thought we knew.
|
00:00:41.320 |
Here were the pillars of Hercules marked the threshold of the un-peopleed world,
|
00:00:46.120 |
the moon draws nearer to earth than she was want and makes men mad.
|
00:00:52.720 |
The true and the life-surgeic are convertible.
|
00:00:55.920 |
Knowledge forged by hallucinations,
|
00:00:58.920 |
comrade Jambati Savikha, "ignorance is a mother of wonder
|
00:01:04.640 |
and made everything wondrous to men who were ignorant of everything."
|
00:01:09.680 |
James Joyce, "river run, past even atoms from swerve of shore to bend of bay,
|
00:01:18.160 |
brings us by a commodious vikas of recirculation back to
|
00:01:23.200 |
the south castle and environs."
|
00:01:27.440 |
Thus begins Finnegan's wake in the very middle.
|
00:01:31.400 |
We begin in the middle and spend the rest of our lives trying to catch up with where it all started.
|
00:01:38.240 |
Stay tuned friends, we're going to float down the incomodious vikas of recirculation,
|
00:01:43.960 |
wherever it leads.
|
00:01:45.640 |
A show on James Joyce and Finnegan's wake coming up.
|
00:01:48.640 |
[Music]
|
00:02:02.400 |
Stole the macula.
|
00:02:04.560 |
[Music]
|
00:02:13.600 |
Today's show is a follow-up to the monologue on Jambati Savikha's new science that aired a couple of weeks ago on entitled opinions.
|
00:02:22.560 |
I'm joined in KZSU by Corey Danserow, a graduate student in Stanford's program of modern thought and literature,
|
00:02:31.040 |
who is finishing up an extravagant dissertation about James Joyce's Finnegan's wake,
|
00:02:37.040 |
and its influence on psychedelic literature and thought.
|
00:02:41.600 |
You can't write a dissertation about Finnegan's wake and not know something about Vico's new science,
|
00:02:47.280 |
which had a decisive influence on Joyce when he set out to write his super novel.
|
00:02:52.240 |
Corey Danserow is a longtime member of the entitled opinions brigade,
|
00:02:58.160 |
so let me not to the marriage of true minds admit impediments.
|
00:03:02.320 |
Corey, welcome to the program.
|
00:03:04.160 |
Hi Robert, thanks so much for bringing me in.
|
00:03:06.160 |
So you're no stranger to the new science.
|
00:03:08.400 |
In fact, you were my teaching collaborator in the last two seminars that I've taught on Vico.
|
00:03:13.840 |
The first time was back in 2019, and then once again this past academic year.
|
00:03:19.440 |
So before we plunge into Joyce, could you tell our listeners what drew you to Vico in the first place?
|
00:03:26.000 |
Yes, what drew me to Vico is his legendary role in the composition of Finnegan's wake.
|
00:03:30.400 |
Joyce seems to know about this Vico connection, but few of them study the new science with a
|
00:03:34.080 |
dedication proportionate to its presence in Finnegan's wake.
|
00:03:36.800 |
So I felt lucky, privileged really, to have the opportunity to do that with you, Robert,
|
00:03:41.040 |
first in 2019, and again in 2020, would grab me right off the bat was because weirdness,
|
00:03:45.120 |
the first page of his autobiography, where he attributes his genius to a childhood school fracture.
|
00:03:49.280 |
Last week I fell headfirst from a window onto a bathroom floor in New York City,
|
00:03:52.320 |
and I instantaneously thought of Vico, and I wondered if I would emerge with a philosophical
|
00:03:56.480 |
golden bow like he did. Something similar happened to Jack Kerra back in the late 50s.
|
00:03:59.840 |
He fell down and entered what he called the golden eternity.
|
00:04:02.000 |
And maybe I'll mention that later.
|
00:04:03.280 |
But yes, what drew me further into Vico when I started reading the new science was its psychedelic
|
00:04:07.600 |
quality. It's extravagant shimmering, billowing prose, but also its content, which is nothing less
|
00:04:12.160 |
than a psychedelic science of man. I mean, a hallucinogenic theory of the origins of humankind.
|
00:04:16.720 |
At the time I was involved in some research and teaching in the psychiatry and behavioral science
|
00:04:20.160 |
department and reading authors like Argorton, Watson, Aldous Huxley, and Terrence McKenna,
|
00:04:23.520 |
each of whom advocated a version of the view that in the beginning was the drug.
|
00:04:26.880 |
For instance, Huxley, man was a dope head before he was a farmer, or a McKenna's so-called
|
00:04:30.640 |
"stone-to-ape theory" that changed in climatic conditions after the less ice age,
|
00:04:34.560 |
brought art distant ancestors into contact with psychoactive mushrooms, which broke them out of
|
00:04:38.240 |
their monkey egos, into proto-human, social consciousness, and behavior.
|
00:04:41.440 |
So in 2019, I was amazed to find that these fringe theories of anthropology are actually
|
00:04:45.520 |
variations on Vico's theory of harmonization. What do I mean by that? I'll assume our audience
|
00:04:49.520 |
is listening closely to your monologue on Vico, especially the part about the primitive religions.
|
00:04:53.280 |
Those lightning bolts that shock the giants are not what they seem. If we read closely, we
|
00:04:57.280 |
notice that they are not just a meteorological phenomenon, a perturbation of the sky that
|
00:05:01.200 |
discloses the sky, but also a technique of perturbing the mind, opening an inner sky,
|
00:05:05.200 |
and elicit science, he calls it, "an illicit science of inducing those first thoughts of divinity,
|
00:05:09.520 |
an inspiring divine speech." Vico writes that the theological poets perturbed themselves to
|
00:05:13.600 |
access with a view to the end of producing sublime poetry, elsewhere he says that they sang the
|
00:05:17.760 |
marvels wrought by sources, note the wording there. The song itself was the marvel, the product
|
00:05:22.320 |
of the sorcery. Vico continues in the same passage, this is to be explained by a hidden sense that
|
00:05:26.560 |
the nations have the omnipotence of God, the art or science of opening that occult sense, tuning
|
00:05:32.400 |
subjects to the invisible electric body of Joe, Enlio, Jupiter, etc., some highest institution of
|
00:05:37.120 |
every nation. Every nation then is born of hallucination. Indeed, the Gentile deities are hallucinations.
|
00:05:43.040 |
Vico insists that there are projections of juvenile egos who mistake their imagination for reality
|
00:05:46.880 |
and disseminate their self-deception to others, forming a collective mental space, a nation.
|
00:05:51.360 |
Maloy, a political scientist and our latest seminar, coined the phrase "hallucinatory political theory"
|
00:05:55.520 |
In your monologue, you said that Vico had reason to worry about running foul of the Inquisition, and indeed,
|
00:05:59.920 |
he almost seems to be advocating kind of atheism, saying that all gods or hallucinations accept
|
00:06:03.920 |
that he maintains a distinction between the Gentiles' pseudo-divine hallucinations and the
|
00:06:07.760 |
Judo-Christian revelation. The course run by Gentile nations is in every case a long strange
|
00:06:12.560 |
trip away from a hallucinatory origin, a depressive fall, out of a super-energetic poetic ecstasy
|
00:06:17.760 |
or mania passing through an intermediate phase, which heroic efforts are made to realize, can serve,
|
00:06:22.080 |
and extend the manic visions finally ending in the ambiguous completion and disenchantment of the
|
00:06:26.080 |
human age. History is an end-static process by which I mean a process wherein things move
|
00:06:30.960 |
from a state of ecstatic inflation back into what they really are. For in the beginning,
|
00:06:34.400 |
men mistook their egos for a supernatural cosmic order. By the third age, imagination has dried
|
00:06:39.040 |
up in sober reason prevailed and it becomes clear that the gods were just human projections
|
00:06:42.400 |
and everyone's really human. Metaphorical poetic language resolves into generic,
|
00:06:45.760 |
prosaic language. One of the practical question for Vico is how to treat the depressive symptoms
|
00:06:49.840 |
of all two human ages without opening the floodgates to delusional and destructive manias,
|
00:06:54.000 |
what he calls chaos of the metaphysical poets. I call this historical therapy,
|
00:06:58.960 |
that is, the work of healing history itself rejuvenating without rebistializing.
|
00:07:03.600 |
All of this is what captivated me about Vico even put me in a frenzy as Misha Lei put it.
|
00:07:07.840 |
On the one hand, I felt that I had landed on a secret subterranean continent on which all
|
00:07:11.520 |
modern psychedelic thought and culture should rest. I'll be it later. I discovered that the CIA
|
00:07:16.080 |
were under the influence of Vico when they planned to turn America onto LSD. On the other hand,
|
00:07:19.920 |
Vico's therapeutic product gave me a lens for understanding Fennigan's wake, not least,
|
00:07:23.360 |
understanding Joyce's own complicated perspective on revivals of ancient religion and
|
00:07:26.800 |
pharmacotheology already underway in his time. And we could certainly use some kind of lens
|
00:07:30.720 |
on Fennigan's wake. As it says somewhere, the further back we managed to wiggle the more we
|
00:07:35.040 |
need the loan of a lens to see what the hand saw and by the way, the hand is always
|
00:07:38.640 |
upon on Ta-Hen, the metaphysical one, the Greek word for the one.
|
00:07:42.160 |
Partly the interruption, Corey, I just want to ask a question about Fennigan's wake and psychedelics
|
00:07:47.040 |
and your perception of what's going on in Fennigan's wake. Does one have to be on psychedelics
|
00:07:52.640 |
in order to understand Fennigan's wake and notoriously difficult, if not illegible, work?
|
00:07:58.000 |
Does one need to have taken psychedelics or even currently beyond one in order to understand the
|
00:08:01.680 |
wake? Probably not. Marshall McLuhan reported that acid has claimed Fennigan's wake is just
|
00:08:06.160 |
like LSD, but McLuhan himself had never tripped yet. He read the wake religiously,
|
00:08:10.320 |
Same with Joseph Campbell, whose wake inspired mono-myth guide at so many trips without himself
|
00:08:14.240 |
ever having tripped. He got there just by reading reading as he put it.
|
00:08:17.920 |
Timothy Leary, for his part, said Joyce's prose prepared him to take psychedelics,
|
00:08:21.760 |
made him desire them even before he knew they existed, and gave him the idea of a side
|
00:08:25.360 |
clotron, a mental Adam Smasher. When he first started running drug experiments at Harvard,
|
00:08:29.360 |
there was a sensationally popular lecture on Fennigan's wake that same semester, and I think Leary's
|
00:08:32.960 |
concept of psychedelic experience as the death of the mind harkens to the opening pages of
|
00:08:36.800 |
Fennigan's wake, where the hero embarks to Amnti, an a mental place. Fennigan's wake is about what
|
00:08:42.160 |
goes on in the mind's absence, and the prose demonstrates this. This raw data mashing without
|
00:08:46.960 |
stable concepts and underworld, where order is provided not by transcendental intellect, but by
|
00:08:51.760 |
imminent feelings of terror and fascination. Maybe psychedel can help attune us to this style,
|
00:08:55.920 |
but really the only way to make headway at all is with a high degree of clear-headed focus,
|
00:09:00.080 |
what you in your recent episode on Ammar Moon, we call it "Lamplight Love" and a good set of annotations.
|
00:09:04.800 |
To reapproach your question in a different way though, I think Fennigan's wake can be
|
00:09:08.080 |
elucidated by a psychedelic lens, a psychedelic in Viconian. I mean, it's very concretely.
|
00:09:12.880 |
Several passages in the overture evoke the scenario of a shamanic initiation, a pharmaceutical
|
00:09:17.680 |
vision quest, or what Peter Kingsley calls "incubation." This folds together with Vico's philosophical
|
00:09:22.800 |
quest, as I described earlier, a descent out of these civilized nature of ours back into the
|
00:09:27.040 |
Arcana of psychohistory, the heroic and divine ages, in search of a restorative power for a
|
00:09:31.440 |
senile into press nation, a kind of controlled recorso whereby a resurrection or
|
00:09:35.520 |
refreshment will hopefully occur. Very late in Fennigan's wake there, indications that we're
|
00:09:39.200 |
coming down back into the present concrete world and voice says, "We have enjoyed the secret
|
00:09:43.760 |
workings of nature. Nature here must be heard in the Viconian sense of birth, the Nashimento of a
|
00:09:49.040 |
nation leaving aside from another question of what nation?" If you look at the back of Fennigan's wake
|
00:09:53.440 |
or listen to most commentators on it, you'll hear that it is about sleep. I think that's too narrow
|
00:09:58.240 |
in the ballad, Fennigan's wake, the young Tim Fennigan has fallen down while deeply intoxicated and
|
00:10:02.560 |
so unconscious that he seems to be dead. He isn't asleep. In letters Joyce referred to Tim Fennigan as
|
00:10:07.760 |
that shying toad, a German word for suspended animation or a trance-like state. Joyceans will declare
|
00:10:13.120 |
things like, "Though little is agreed upon about the wake, it is universally agreed that it begins
|
00:10:16.800 |
where Ulysses ends with Leopold going to bed, Leopold bloom that is. But it's just as possible, I think,
|
00:10:21.440 |
to say that the wake begins with the climax of Ulysses were Stephen Daedalus, whom the Theosophist
|
00:10:25.200 |
medic, Bach Mulligan has dosed with an ancient Greek sacrament, collapses at the peak of a philosophical
|
00:10:29.600 |
frenzy. His stream of consciousness drops out for fifty pages. I think the wake brings us into that
|
00:10:34.560 |
concealed, liminal state, a state of suspense of ex-animation, a revelatory near-death experience.
|
00:10:40.720 |
Joyce also sometimes cites Thomas de Quincy at key moments of Fennigan's wake, and I think the
|
00:10:44.320 |
book should be conceived less in terms of sleep and dreaming than of a kind of epiphenic flash,
|
00:10:48.240 |
de Quincy attributes to opium or near-death experiences, in which all encompassing visions of life
|
00:10:53.040 |
in the hidden structures of the cosmos were revealed. And again, for Joyce this folds together with
|
00:10:56.400 |
the vaconian therapeutic mission into the Arcana of Mental History, a controlled
|
00:11:00.000 |
recourse so to rejuvenate a terminal human age. As the rational humanist subject goes down,
|
00:11:04.640 |
archaic, magical theological archetypes swing up, the theological poet, the patriarch, the founder
|
00:11:09.120 |
of nations, and Vico, these are three aspects of a single figure, but Joyce defracts them into
|
00:11:12.800 |
three characters. A father, known by his initials HCE, and his two sons, one of whom is a writer,
|
00:11:17.360 |
Shem the Penman, and the other a civil servant, Shem the Post. You could say that HCE represents the
|
00:11:22.160 |
divine age, Shem the heroic age, Shem the human age. Shem after all is a universalist philosopher,
|
00:11:27.040 |
Bolschovic, maybe involved in a plot to tear down his father HCE. Shem is a mediator between his father
|
00:11:31.920 |
and his brother, a conformist who scorns Shem, but nevertheless wants to learn something from him.
|
00:11:36.080 |
But we'll get into trouble if we try to hold these distinctions, that's true of the wake in general,
|
00:11:39.520 |
any attempt to separate things out in unstable concepts will come to grief. I'm more confident that
|
00:11:43.120 |
the father and each of the sons reflect an aspect of the first age, a divine archetype trying to
|
00:11:47.600 |
revive itself in restore spirit and meaning in an all too human age. With the danger of returning to
|
00:11:52.320 |
gigantic, the patriarch HCE is introduced as a capitalist, Freemason, colligialist, submerging his
|
00:11:57.200 |
head in alcohol and hallucinating celestial architecture. Throughout the book he's being investigated
|
00:12:01.360 |
and or scapegoated as a powerful, theo-political conspirator and pedophile who flashed young girls in the
|
00:12:05.680 |
park. The poet's son, the metaphysician, Shem the Penman, the chapter about him is styled as an
|
00:12:09.920 |
expose by a scandalized, populist press. He takes mushrooms and flies like a reindeer by the light
|
00:12:14.880 |
fantastic of his noses glow, noses spelled with a G. He's infected with various diseases and
|
00:12:19.680 |
including Europikolas, a disease related to the hallucinogenic fungus Ergot. His infections are
|
00:12:25.360 |
always also secret initiations. He's the sole contracted son of the secret cell and he's writing a
|
00:12:30.000 |
baconian book that fuses all cycle-wealing history in a single present tense. In another chapter,
|
00:12:34.480 |
his story is told in the first person and it's overlaid with Dr. Jackles saga with transcendental
|
00:12:39.600 |
medication. Finally, Sean, the older brother is a civic figure, a doctor, a hygienist and
|
00:12:44.720 |
eugenist and a hierarchy and a shady power structure. He's the wakes equivalent of Buck Mulligan
|
00:12:49.600 |
from Ulysses, but he also corresponds to Joyce's real-life childhood friend, Selzger Gunn, who had
|
00:12:53.360 |
become the vice president of the Rockefeller Foundation. The opening pages, Finn and Zwick,
|
00:12:56.800 |
depict the poet and the doctor, statesman, locked in a magical duel on a boat on a river to the
|
00:13:00.800 |
underworld. And one aspect of the book's shamanic initiatory plot structure is that Gunn is being
|
00:13:05.200 |
initiated into a medical, magical, or magical cult out of ancient Egypt. Tracking Gunn throughout the
|
00:13:10.800 |
book gives a picture of reminiscent of Tacitus' theme of the Arkana in Peery, the mysteries,
|
00:13:14.880 |
or secrets of empire, and anticipate the joycy and conspiracy fictions of Thomas Pinchon.
|
00:13:19.120 |
Joyce's paranoid fascination with Rockefeller human science projects,
|
00:13:22.160 |
narco-capitalist machinations. The Sandos Farm-Sudical Company, which made LSD,
|
00:13:27.120 |
global electronic media, and Gnostic Apocolipticism. All of these come together in the
|
00:13:31.520 |
fantastic image in Book II, Chapter 1, of the Global Theater operated by Selzger Gunn,
|
00:13:36.160 |
showing the radium wedding of night and morning, and peace, perfect pure and perpetual.
|
00:13:40.960 |
And this in Book's Kant, of course, but "nied" means envy in German. This is another of the
|
00:13:45.680 |
underappreciated themes of Finn and Gensweik. This proto-Girardian investigation of envy.
|
00:13:49.840 |
Gunn is often depicted manipulating people and indeed taking over the world using the green worm of
|
00:13:54.560 |
envy. The ethical plot of the book is that the giant poet, Shem, or Joyce, is watching and
|
00:13:58.720 |
judging the giant statesman, Sean, or Gunn. As they both traverse the underworld, the poet's pen interlocked
|
00:14:04.400 |
with a medic's syringe, the poet trying to master the medic, such that he finally shapes up into
|
00:14:08.560 |
illegitimate monarch rather than an occult and our co-tyrant, which for Vico is the only non-catastrophic
|
00:14:14.000 |
outcome of the human age. Corey, you're starting to sound to me like lucky and Beckett's
|
00:14:18.960 |
waiting for Goudo? Well, that's very interesting to say that, Robert, because when lucky gives
|
00:14:22.960 |
that Finn against Wagestyle speech, I think Beckett is giving a depiction of the relation between
|
00:14:27.040 |
Joyce and Susqueh Ghan, who I just mentioned. Lucky is a slave and a kind of court fool to
|
00:14:31.520 |
Potsso in a curious power wielder who's playing God. He speaks at Potsso's behest, and though he
|
00:14:35.920 |
doesn't address anyone in particular, it's Potsso who understands him. Indeed, Potsso is violently
|
00:14:40.240 |
affected by the speech and finally forces Lucky to stop. To me, it's clear that lucky speech mimics
|
00:14:44.560 |
and satirizes Potsso's claim to mastery of the world. And I think this is Beckett's microscopic
|
00:14:48.640 |
representation of Finn against Wagislich, which he helped Joyce to write. Like Lucky, Joyce is speaking
|
00:14:52.480 |
to know and in particular, speaking to anyone speaking into the ether, but also speaking to the
|
00:14:56.640 |
ruling intelligentsia, who funded him and who will read him in the universities for the next 300 years.
|
00:15:00.800 |
But also more immediately, he's addressed some gun, the social medical commissar of the Rockefeller
|
00:15:04.640 |
Foundation, whose quasi metaphysical ambition to heal and control the world, Joyce,
|
00:15:08.720 |
Mox and Wake.
|
00:15:09.600 |
Corey, I'm going to interrupt you again and ask, because I mentioned at the beginning that your
|
00:15:13.680 |
dissertation is not just about Finn against Wake, but it's about its reception among a number of
|
00:15:19.440 |
American protagonists. And I would like before we run out of time or energy here for you to say
|
00:15:27.360 |
something about that.
|
00:15:28.320 |
Yes, as far as Joyce's reception in America, very early on, we have Eric Fogel and who frequent
|
00:15:33.040 |
Shakespeare in co-imparison, eagerly read Joyce's work in progress as it emerged. John Cage
|
00:15:38.480 |
bought Finn against Wake in Seattle the year it was released 1939. Then of course there's
|
00:15:42.240 |
Joseph Campbell and Henry Robinson whose skeleton key to Finn against Wake was a heroic effort
|
00:15:46.000 |
of condensation and summary, heroic and sheer speed, appearing on the five years after the publication
|
00:15:51.200 |
of the Wake, overhasteed perhaps, and perhaps it's significant to lay more in announcing the
|
00:15:55.520 |
arrival of Campbell himself. In any case, the skeleton key was crucial to the Wake's reception
|
00:16:00.160 |
in America, especially when it was republished to the turn of the 60s and I'll return to that.
|
00:16:03.520 |
Marshall McLuhan, his early essays on Joyce before McLuhan was famous, are quite amazing and strange.
|
00:16:08.880 |
I recommend especially the essay Joyce Aquinas and the poetic process. He begins by quoting
|
00:16:13.040 |
an early poem by Joyce in which he scoffs at other writers, souls who lack the strength that
|
00:16:16.960 |
mine has, steeled in the school of old Aquinas, including thanks Joyce's epiphanic streams of
|
00:16:21.920 |
consciousness are a rigorous application of Aquinas's theory of the stages of cognition. McLuhan
|
00:16:26.480 |
likes to refer to this as a vivisection of the mind in action. In turn, he refers Aquinas's
|
00:16:30.960 |
theory to the Aleucinian mysteries, but I'm not going to talk about that. Before moving on to the
|
00:16:35.280 |
Joyce and writers of the beat, movement and psychedelic counterculture, I want to mention that Campbell
|
00:16:38.640 |
and McLuhan collaborated on a social science project at the turn of the 60s, an attempted design
|
00:16:43.360 |
and mythology that would inspire America and bring on a new age of global culture. The leader of
|
00:16:47.200 |
the project was the Harvard social psychologist, Henry Murray, who tapped Campbell and McLuhan for
|
00:16:50.880 |
his 1959 edition of "Deadless Magazine," before discussing that issue of "Deadless a Little
|
00:16:55.120 |
Vaconian Backstory" as an order. Murray was a "America's Leading Psychologist," he wrote in an extraordinary
|
00:16:59.120 |
literary style that drew comparisons to William James. He was also a leading Melville scholar, pivotal in
|
00:17:02.960 |
the canonization of Melville. During the war, he was recruited by William Donovan to be the chief
|
00:17:06.320 |
professor and selector of intelligence agencies for the Office of Strategic Services, the
|
00:17:09.360 |
precursor to the CIA that could continue to succeed from the early in the future, following the
|
00:17:12.960 |
demonstration of the comic power in 1945. Murray, "Sennon Sonomati, non-Levaljama," I'm Robert Harrison for
|
00:17:20.240 |
entitled "Pinience."
|
00:17:36.240 |
[Music]
|
00:18:04.240 |
[Music]
|
00:18:14.240 |
[Music]
|
00:18:24.240 |
[Music]
|
00:18:34.240 |
[Music]
|
00:18:44.240 |
[Music]
|
00:18:54.240 |
[Music]
|
00:19:04.240 |
[Music]
|
00:19:32.240 |
[BLANK_AUDIO]
|